Spurred on by an ESPN.com poll asking who I would build a franchise around excluding Kobe and LeBron, I have decided to tackle that topic here. The options were Dwight Howard, CP3, D-Wade, and other. I, on a second's thought, chose CP3 thinking that Howard would be ineffective without a good point guard and some perimeter shooting, and that D-Wade doesn't have what it takes to be a franchise leader. Despite his championship success, he just gives off this vibe, like he's a great scorer and everything but is he really going to be good enough in the other areas to lead his team without a great wingman (Posey) and two interior forces (Shaq & Zo) and a supreme outside scorer (Kapono)? I don't think so. But before we get into details, how about some guys who could be considered in the "other" category? Melo, Devin Harris, Danny Granger, CB4, Derrick Rose, OJ Mayo, Deron Williams and Brandon Roy seem to be prime candidates.So that's it: Howard-CP3-Wade-Melo-Harris-Granger-Bosh-Rose-Mayo-Roy-Williams
The criteria will be clutch scoring, leadership qualities, off-court behavior, natural basketball talent, age, and their play from the last two years.
I'm gonna start by throwing Ovinton J'Anthony Mayo, Brandon Roy and Chris Bosh off the island. I've been really disappointed in Bosh's play of late, he can't hold his own against bigger, stronger guys (like Howard), and so he has to be one of the first eliminated. Though Mayo seems to be a Kobe-esque scorer, he doesn't have the other intangibles to be a long-term franchise player for a successful team and is second-to-last among these players in clutch scoring. Roy might be one of the hardest working guys in the league, and he's also #7 in the NBA in clutch scoring, averaging 40.5 points per 48 minutes of clutch time (defined as 4th quarter or overtime, less than 5 minutes left, neither team ahead by more than 5 points), that's 4th on this list. (1 and 2 are Kobe, LeBron and 6 is Paul Pierce) He's a great player, but he's probably the least talented of all the guys on this list, so he's got to go too.
Round 2: Howard-CP3-Wade-Melo-Harris-Granger-Rose-Williams
Next to go are Harris and Granger. Harris's recent tiff with Coach Frank has me worried about his leadership qualities. Frankly, despite his terrific play this season, I haven't been thoroughly convinced that he has the skills to be a superstar. Granger, whom I love, is in the middle of the pack in terms of clutch scoring, but that's disappointing considering he's fifth in the NBA in scoring. Shows a lack of clutch-time leadership to me, and hasn't been able to lift his team to success yet. The Pacers obviously don't have great talent, but they have enough to be at least middle of the pack with a player of Granger's ability.
Round 3: Howard-CP3-Wade-Melo-Rose-Williams
Melo and Williams are going to be the losers of Round 3. Melo leads this list in clutch points, but his points per game have gone down each of the past three seasons, and I see him as a liablity on the defensive end. He also needs a good point guard to help him out, which is why Billups has been such an improvement for the Nuggets. Deron is another guy whose numbers are going down this year, from 18.5 (points) and 10.5 (assists) to 17.6 and 10.1. This isn't a significant drop, but you want to see improvement at this time in his career. He's also the third worst clutch scorer on the remaining list, ahead of Rose and Howard.
Semifinals: Howard-CP3-Wade-Rose

And the losers in the semifinals: Rose and Howard. Most people probably expected it to come down to Howard and Paul so this might be a slight shocker. However, despite leading the league in rebounds and blocks (amazing!), Howard is the last of all the guys in clutch scoring, 85th in the league at 19.6 per 48 minutes. Again, he's a guy who needs a solid point guard and good perimeter play to dominate, so he's not the best choice to build a franchise around. Rose is only in his rookie year so it's hard to gauge his performance. He's been very impressive, and looks to be a great future talent, but he's only 16th in the league in assists. He's also the worst remaining clutch scorer coming in at number 36.
So that leaves us with a Finals showdown of
Chris Paul vs. Dwayne WadeThey are third and fourth in the league in clutch scoring, behind Kobe and LeBron. Wade averages 50.6 per 48 and Paul 49.8. Paul is #1 in the NBA in assists averaging 10.9 per game, down slightly from last year, but his scoring is up about half a point per game as well. Paul is also first in steals with 2.48 per game, and set the record for consecutive games with a steal at 108 regular-season games. He's averaging just 3.1 turnovers per game. Paul averages 21.5 ppg and 5.4 rebounds per game. Wade leads the NBA in scoring, averaging 28.5 points per game (a career-high) and is also near his career-mark for assists (7.2 this season). He averages 2.1 steals, 5.0 rebounds per game and 3.5 turnovers per game. I'm going to settle this debate with simple math.
1 PPG = 1 Point
1 Assist Per Game = 1.5 Points
1 Clutch Point Per 48 = 2 Points1 Turnover Per Game = -1.5 Points
1 Steal Per Game = 1 Point1 Rebound Per Game = 1 PointMINUS their age (CP3 is 23 and Wade is 27)
PLUS their championships (1 for wade)
And the final tally is:
117.68 to 116.35A narrow win for Chris Paul. I guess my original feelings were right on this one.